Why Plan 9 Failed: A Look at the Best Operating System Ever
Based on Thompson says Plan 9 "the best operating system out there" but will "never make it, ever, ever." by Turing Awardee Clips
Plan 9 was a superior operating system that failed to gain widespread adoption because it lacked a web browser during the critical rise of the internet.
The Legacy of Plan 9
In this video, the speaker reflects on Plan 9, an operating system he considers the best ever created, yet one that ultimately failed to gain traction. He explains that despite its technical brilliance, it lacked the necessary applications—most notably a web browser—at a time when the internet was becoming essential, which sealed its fate.
Key Features of Plan 9
Designed primarily by Rob Pike, Plan 9 introduced revolutionary concepts that were ahead of their time. Key aspects included:
- Networked Architecture: The system was built to allow multiple machines to connect and communicate as if they were in the same room, regardless of their physical location.
- Unified Interface: Users could interact with a terminal, keyboard, and mouse, with Plan 9 multiplexing these inputs to control various remote machines.
- File System Protocol: The entire system was based on a multiplexed protocol of open, close, read, and write operations. A single line of this protocol could simulate a file system, creating an entire hierarchy of files.
- WORM Storage: The file system was backed by WORM (Write Once, Read Many) technology, essentially a writable CD. This provided a reliable, read-only layer for files, while writable parts were stored on disk.
Design Philosophy
The speaker highlights how the system's design allowed for efficient backups. When a user initiated a split or backup, the system created a version of the old state and maintained a directory of all previous versions. This approach was highly economical in terms of space. The speaker contrasts this with modern programming, where changes are often widespread and complex, making the simple, isolated copy-and-restore method of Plan 9 difficult to implement today.